Section: Features

Mount Vernon’s Fat Dog Vinyl is every Horn kid’s oasis

When Cecilia Duffy ’27 tells people she works at the record store in Mount Vernon, the most common response she gets is, “There’s a record store in Mount Vernon?”

Duffy and her roommate discovered Fat Dog Vinyl on the corner of the square on North Main Street this summer while she was on campus working on summer research. “Once we found it, we were probably in here at least once a week, if not more,” she said.

They browsed the bins and chatted music with the owner, Phil Hicks. Before long, Hicks offered her a job. “I love it. It actually makes me so happy,” Duffy said. “I love getting to just talk to people about music all day.”

The inspiration for the store was Hicks’ son. When his son traveled for soccer tournaments, a few of his   teammates always wanted to hit the local record stores afterward. “So, after doing that for a couple of years, I came home and said to my wife, we should open a record store,” Hicks said. “And I fully expected her to say, ‘No way, you’re crazy. We’re not gonna do that.’ And she was like, ‘Yeah, that sounds like a great idea.’”

From that day to Fat Dog Vinyl’s opening day in 2022 was about five months. “I mean, our whole house was just filled with records at one point,” he said.

Music has been a constant for Hicks throughout his life. “My parents divorced when I was, I think, nine, so sports and music became my escape from that,” he said. His first record, a Christmas gift, was KISS’ Alive! A few Christmases later came Pink Floyd’s The Wall. He still remembers a holiday at his grandparents’ house when the Bee Gees’ “Nights on Broadway” played while his family laughed together. At about 11 years old, the “cool kid on [his] block,” Greg Norris, drove him to Dairy Queen in a purple AMC Gremlin with Frampton Comes Alive! on the stereo. “I was in heaven. Cruising around with the cool guy listening to great tunes was the apex,” Hicks said.

After graduating from The Ohio State University, Hicks went into sales and pharmaceuticals with stints in Chicago and Indiana before moving back to Ohio. But he’s dreamed of owning his own store since he was a kid.  “And then, you know, the more I got into music, and the more my son got into music, the dream became a reality,” he said.

Duffy said it’s clear that the store is a labor of love. “He’s always just so excited to talk about music,” she said. “Sometimes record stores can be intimidating for people, because they feel like they’ll get judged for listening to pop music, or something not super indie or alternative. But if you go in and want to chop it up about Olivia Rodrigo or Sabrina Carpenter, he’ll do that with people. He’s just excited that you’re also a fan of music.”

Hicks buys online and at record fairs, and a couple of times a week someone will sell a collection. Some finds surprise even the staff: “I had a guy the other day — I had no idea we had this — buy an album of Ronald Reagan reading the Old Testament,” Duffy said. 

For Hicks, running a record store has “kind of reenergized [his] take on humanity.” “People walk in, and they start smiling immediately, and everybody is just super cool, and they leave with a smile. So that’s probably the greatest thing about having a shop.”

Now Duffy wants more students to find the store. She’s planning record sales on campus, trying to get a K-Card reader for the store. “I know a lot of people here will go all the way to Columbus to go to record stores,” Duffy said, “and we have one right here.”

0 Comments

Comments for this article have closed. If you'd like to send a letter to the editor for publication, please email us at collegian@kenyon.edu.